logo

45 pages 1 hour read

Nawal El Saadawi

Woman at Point Zero

Fiction | Novella | Adult | Published in 1975

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Effects of Patriarchal Domination on Egyptian Women

Content Warning: This section includes descriptions of child sexual abuse, sexual assault and rape, physical violence, and domestic abuse.

The course of Firdaus’s life runs like a long-winding river, challenged constantly by obstacles that test its courage, power, and strength. Firdaus grew up in 20th-century Egypt during the final years of British rule and the political upheaval that followed. Egypt is still a largely patriarchal society, and Firdaus’s personal values of womanhood and autonomy clash with the ideals perpetuated by patriarchal ideals. Nawal El Saadawi was so deeply moved by Firdaus’s story that she felt the need to share it with the world because Firdaus’s story is one of mental and emotional triumph over the patriarchic bindings that attempt to hold her and all women like her back. As secularism rose in Egypt during this period, more and more women awoke to the injustices of religious dogma.

Firdaus’s childhood is fraught with abuse and neglect, and she’s expected to be subservient, innocent, and insignificant as a female. She has endured female genital mutilation, incestual molestation, and physical abuse. She comments on how indifferent her father was when one of her sisters died, and on how frequently he would beat her mother into submission. As a young girl, she asks herself, “Who was I? Who was my father? Was I going to spend my life sweeping the dung out from under the animals, carrying manure on my head, kneading dough, and baking bread?” (16). Firdaus is intelligent and knows she wants and deserves more, so when her uncle takes her to Cairo and enrolls her in school, she thinks she may finally break free. Unfortunately, her uncle reflects the common patriarchal belief that women shouldn’t attend university, and her education ends with secondary school. Firdaus wants a man she can genuinely admire and respect, but every man in her life disappoints her. She relishes what education she does get and reads about the patriarchal systems that led to the current one, noting how the past seems full of men who were of an “avaricious and distorted personality” (27). They cared about nothing but sex and power, and Firdaus encounters the same sort of men throughout her life. As a young adult, she experiences a romantic attraction to Miss Iqbal but is so repressed by patriarchy and the black-and-white moralistic ideals of religion that she fails to understand her own feelings. Soon after this, she’s forced to marry a man half a century older than her and submit to his sexual advances and beatings. When she seeks her uncle’s protection, his wife tells her that it’s perfectly “normal” for a husband to treat his wife that way:

She replied that it was precisely men well versed in their religion who beat their wives. The precepts of religion permitted such punishment. A virtuous woman was not supposed to complain about her husband. Her duty was perfect obedience (44).

When Firdaus matures into womanhood and slowly discovers herself, her beauty, and her power as a woman who can use men’s desire to her own advantage, her perspective changes, but the men around her don’t. She’s regularly met by men who claim to want to protect her but soon reveal themselves as abusive and greedy. Even Sharifa takes advantage of Firdaus, though Sharifa also imparts some wisdom to Firdaus that helps her overcome the pain she feels: “A man does not know a woman’s value, Firdaus. She is the one who determines her value” (55). When a client tells her that her profession isn’t respectable, every memory of abuse and subjugation returns to her simultaneously. It fuels within her a rage that she unleashes on a pimp who tries to hold her captive and take her earnings. From then on, Firdaus refuses to submit to the system of fear that is designed to make women feel vulnerable and in need of protection from the very men who harm them:

To protect my deeper, inner self from men, I offered them only an outer shell. I kept my heart and soul, and let my body play its role, its passive, inert, unfeeling role. I learnt to resist by being passive, to keep myself whole by offering nothing, to live by withdrawing to a world of my own (85).

She ruefully notes that all women must sell themselves in some way and that she simply chose to do so in a way that maintained her autonomy and freedom. She sees marriage, sex, and love as concepts “built on the most cruel suffering for women” (86) and believes that only sex workers see this reality. Killing the pimp is a symbolic act of revenge against the patriarchy, and though she’s sentenced to death, she remains in the eyes of many women completely innocent.

Resilience and Agency From a Feminist Perspective

Firdaus embodies resiliency and agency. She doesn’t represent just any type of resilience or agency but a sort that exists as a source of power, as something that allows her to overcome the patriarchal system that constantly tries to beat her down. For most of her young life, she has no sense of agency or experience being her own person; she tends to the house, bakes bread, and doesn’t go to school. She does recall how her father once gave her a single piastre and how the ability to choose what she did with it was most meaningful for her. In addition, she shows incredible resilience as she survives extreme abuse and subjugation.

Firdaus’s uncle sends her to school later in her childhood, and by becoming educated she develops even more agency. She learns of the patriarchal systems of the past and becomes intelligent enough to eventually use the system to her own advantage. When she grows up and becomes a sex worker, she has a long, confusing period of trial and error in which she figures out what female agency means to her. At first, Sharifa takes advantage of her, but Firdaus soon learns she can work for herself, deciding her own prices and clientele. When she receives her first 10-pound note from a client, it’s a moment of sheer liberation and represents her newfound control over her own life. In general, women in Egypt during the 20th century had little to no agency in their lives or relationships, and it’s therefore particularly significant when Firdaus finds hers. In murdering the pimp, Firdaus frees herself once and for all:

I was like a women walking through an enchanted world to which she did not belong. She is free to do what she wants, and free not to do it. She experiences the rare pleasure of having no ties with anyone, of having broken with everything, of having cut all relations with the world around her, of being completely independent and living her independence completely, of enjoying freedom from any subjection to a man, to marriage, or to love; of being divorced from all limitations whether rooted in rules and laws in time or in the universe (87).

Continuous attempts are made to rob Firdaus of her agency, including the abuse, control, and captivity she experiences, but she refuses to let it be taken from her when her life concludes. Instead, she remains independent and autonomous by choosing to die.

Freedom From Male Desire and Hypocrisy

Firdaus’s life is defined by the hypocritical desires of men in 20th-century Egyptian society. As a young girl, Firdaus feels as though her ability to feel pleasure is robbed from her by the sexual assaults that her uncle regularly perpetrates against her. From then on, she views desire only from the angle of greed and domination; it became something that embodies the men she encounters and that she therefore took great efforts to avoid herself. Desire seemed to make men “piggish,” uncouth, and grossly self-serving. They frequently take advantage of, buy and sell, and violently abuse Firdaus and other women around her. Firdaus often notices that men look at her as if she’s their property: “I saw them as they watched what went on around them with wary, doubting, stealthy eyes, eyes ready to pounce, full of an aggressiveness that seemed strangely servile” (13). The hypocrisy of the society in which Firdaus lives stems from the religious doctrine that permeates it; this doctrine proclaims to encourage fair and respectful treatment of women but simultaneously props men up and positions women as “lowly objects,” servants, and sources of sex. Firdaus thus sees the men around her as deeply dishonest: They claim to be one way and act another. Firdaus sees a side of these men that everyday society doesn’t.

After enduring a lifetime of being surrounded by hypocrisy and what Firdaus views as foul desires, she learns to rise above it all and use the corruption around her to her own advantage. She lets go of her fear of men, a fear instilled in her from birth, and emerges victorious amid the impossible: “I have triumphed over both life and death because I no longer desire to live, nor do I any longer fear to die. I want nothing. I hope for nothing. I fear nothing. Therefore I am free” (101). Although Firdaus’s execution approaches, she remains utterly calm, and Saadawi sees her as the most courageous of women. The murder that Firdaus committed is one which she believed was necessary to expose a dark truth about men, and she harbors no shame, guilt, or regret. Saadawi reflects on Firdaus’s rare and emboldened perspective on truth and desire, calling Firdaus’s sentencing a reaction to “the fear of the truth which kills, the power of truth, as savage, and as simple, and as awesome as death, yet as simple and as gentle as the child that has not yet learnt to lie” (108).

The Subjectiveness of Guilt and Innocence

Firdaus is convicted of murder for killing the pimp that threatened her life, her autonomy, and her independence. In killing him, she was piercing the world with a truth about the subjugation women face and the extreme consequences that may result when a woman is pushed to the edge. When Saadawi first comes to the prison to meet Firdaus, she’s met by a female warder who clearly has an empathetic perspective toward Firdaus’s circumstances. The warder says, “Murderer or not, she’s an innocent woman and does not deserve to be hanged” (2). This is an introduction to one of the novella’s main convictions: that women who lash out in response to the patriarchy aren’t criminals but are reacting to men’s crimes against them.

Firdaus’s entire line of work is based on an act that was, for most of her life, considered illegal in Egypt. The purchasing of sexual favors was outlawed there in 1951, around the time that Firdaus became a sex worker. Her profession therefore toes a legal line, and she points this out frequently, noting the hypocrisy of the men who claim to be decent yet pay her for sexual favors. She comes to believe that it’s better to be honest about corruption and use it to her advantage than to pretend she’s pure: “A successful prostitute was better than a misled saint” (86). Although her morality differs from that prevalent throughout much of society, she was conditioned to think that way not by religious teachings or school but by her experiences interacting with men. This lifelong conditioning eventually triggered her murder of a pimp, a man who threatened not only her life but her personhood. She accepts her sentencing with grace and fortitude, never faltering or fearing what may await her in death. When she’s accused of being a criminal, she states firmly, “No woman is a criminal. To be a criminal one must be a man” (100). While her opinion of men is extreme and eventually leads to a violent end, she sees it as the only natural course of events and repeats confidently that were she released, she would only continue to kill. She feels no guilt, instead leaving the murder scene with an air of bravado and godlike power, as if she has overcome everything that ever hurt her: “Perhaps they thought I was a princess, or a queen, or a goddess. For whom else would hold her head so high as she walked? And who else’s footsteps could resound in this way as they struck the ground?” (97).

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text