logo

47 pages 1 hour read

Philippe Bourgois, Jeffrey Schonberg

Righteous Dopefiend

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2008

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapter 5Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 5 Summary: “Making Money”

Neoliberal policies profoundly affected the unhoused people of Edgewater people during their lifetimes, particularly policies that relied more on free market forces than regulation, leading to the devastating wealth disparities that were already becoming evident at the time of this book’s publication.

During the 1970s and 80s, Nixon and Reagan’s shift toward neoliberalism meant globalization—the subsequent movement of jobs overseas (where corporations could pay less for labor and could legally exploit workers to a greater degree than in the US) led to a generation of manual workers seeing their jobs become obsolete. Due to the skyrocketing rent as San Francisco became more and more gentrified, many of these manual laborers lost stable housing as they lost their jobs.

These industrial workers were the parents of people living in the Edgewater encampment; their children now cycle in and out of marginalized temporary labor. The jobs that unhoused people work in the run-down, industrial district reflect the gray areas of the legal economy. The few business owners that stay afloat in the area give unhoused people odd jobs, often paying them significantly less than they would other workers, including undocumented workers.

Not only are some of the business owners outright abusive, but legal work with local businesses also perpetuates racial disparities, as business owners prefer to give the limited employment opportunities to white applicants. Even while panhandling, Black people receive far fewer donations than white people do. In speaking with Bourgois and Schonberg, white interlocutors are more likely to aggrandize their legal work history, whereas the Black ones are prouder of their illegal exploits. To maintain dignity and a sense of purpose, both groups are more likely to own the work they can do. Since Black interlocutors had a much more challenging time landing legal employment or accessing social welfare services, illegal jobs were the main ones they could take on.

The chapter ends with a discussion of the direct competition between undocumented Latinx day workers and the unhoused, resulting in ethnic and racial tensions that reflect long-held racial stereotypes in the US.

Chapter 5 Analysis

The people the book profiles were never able to get the stable employment they needed to avoid becoming unhoused; this chapter explores what work looks like for them now. To explain the history of work within the residents’ families of origin, the book zooms out briefly to describe policies that affected the previous generation, illustrating to readers the frameworks of Politically and Institutionally Structured Violence within which the Edgewater residents grew up and are now operating. San Francisco’s industry crashed because of political decisions, as neoliberal ideals of the 1980s and ’90s encouraged the outsourcing of production, weakened labor unions, and pushed wealth inequalities to greater and greater heights amid unprecedented globalization. The forces acting upon the interlocutors and their parents were entirely out of their control or even awareness.

At the same time, neoliberalism places the blame for their situation squarely on the unhoused population rather than acknowledging the root causes of their conditions. A motif the authors frequently return to in characterizing their interlocutors is their universal need to assert human dignity and autonomy in the face of systems that seek to render them powerless. Many residents of places like Edgewater take ownership of their addiction, homelessness, and illegal jobs with a sense of pride, preferring to think of themselves as willful outlaws rather than as passive victims.  

Like most other aspects of life on the street, the experience of employment reflects The Racialization of Poverty, Homelessness, and Addiction. People of color within the community have a hard time overcoming discrimination to attain legal work; one outcome of this is that many of the Black Edgewater residents celebrate their criminal personas, valuing this status over legal employment. Such attitudes serve to further isolate the community, as “the outlaw habitus that offer[s] them a sense of self-respect through asserting control of public space convince[s] those who interact[] with them that they deserve[] their fate,” (186). By highlighting this vicious cycle, Bourgois and Schonberg demonstrate the degree to which structural inequalities lead to forms of intimate harm that only exacerbate inequality.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text