logo

69 pages 2 hours read

Clare Mackintosh

I Let You Go

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2014

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 36-40Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 36 Summary

It is the present day again, and Jenna can’t get up. He is on top of her. Beau is whining, so Ian kicks him. He tells Jenna he knows she has been to the police, and she apologizes. He believes she has told them about him, and she denies it. He then asks if she is seeing someone. He calls her a liar and hits her cheek because he knows she could not have started a new life without help. He mentions her sister, and Jenna thinks she will never forgive herself if something happens to Eve and her family. He forces Jenna to tell him, “I’m nothing” (318). He rapes her and leaves.

 

Jenna thinks she is bleeding afterwards. Beau is all right in the kitchen, but there is a knock at the door. It is Patrick. He wants to know if everything is all right, and she claims she fell asleep on the sofa. He came to apologize. Jenna won’t let him in, though, telling him that she doesn’t want to see him. He doesn’t blame her. She starts to cry. He says he misses her. She lies that she doesn’t want anything to do with him. He runs off. She relates, “I wasn’t able to save Jacob, but I can save Patrick” (321).

 

She calls Iestyn to demand that he fix the broken lock. He comes within an hour. He tells her to keep to herself and let it blow over. She takes a bath, where she examines her bruises. 

Chapter 37 Summary

Mags and Ray are getting ready for a get-together to celebrate the end of the job: Stumpy and Kate are expected. Things are sensitive between them. Ray spent the night on the sofa, and he feels that Mags thinks everything he says seems wrong. He can’t help comparing Mags to Kate. He wonders if a public showdown is coming.

Mags says Tom got a letter from school, which says they want to discuss “an issue that has arisen within the school” (325). Ray thinks the school is finally admitting there’s a problem, that Tom is being bullied. Mags thinks she was a terrible mother to miss this and becomes emotional. The doorbell rings.

 

Kate meets Lucy and Tom, and asks about the bullying. Mags snaps that it is nothing they can’t handle. Ray gets a call from Stumpy, who can’t make it. It’ll be just the three of them. They awkwardly settle down to eat. Mags asks Kate about how she likes CID, and they banter about Ray’s habits at work until Mags makes it awkward again. Kate asks Mags if she misses being on the job. She says yes: “I don’t miss the job, exactly, but I miss the person I was back then. I miss having something to say, something to teach people” (332). Mags goes up to the kids, and Ray apologizes for her, saying that she is worried about Tom. Kate leaves before dessert.

Mags asks Ray to take Stumpy some chili the following day. She says Kate is pretty, but claims she is not jealous. She tells Ray that she loves the fact that the job is part of him, but she feels invisible—like she and the kids exist only in the background. Mags sees a connection between Ray and Kate; it’s only natural, when you’re working all hours with someone. But she reminds him that the kids are growing up and he’s missing it. 

Chapter 38 Summary

Ian, considering the past, knows that Jenna never forgave him for Venice. On their first anniversary, he buys her a book on the artist Auguste Rodin and they go out to dinner. When she tells him she might teach an adult education class, he reminds her that those who can’t, teach. She brings up the idea of having a separate bank account for her business. He nixes the idea and asks if she wants more cash. When she says she needs more clothes, he offers to come shopping with her.

 

As they leave, he falls against a waiter and Jenna apologizes for Ian’s drunkenness. He pinches her arm, telling her never to do that. That night in bed, she apologizes and tries to initiate sex, but he can’t get aroused, and blames her. “’You don’t turn me on anymore,’ I said” (339).

 

Ian relates that after Jenna stops trying in bed, he starts looking elsewhere and stops coming home on Friday nights. He tries to see how far he can push her. One day, watching British football (soccer) she asks about Charlotte. He turns off the TV and lights a cigarette. When she asks him to smoke outside, he reminds her it is his house. He says he has no idea who Charlotte is, and hopes she is not accusing him of anything. He realizes she is wearing something revealing and asks if she went out like that. He accuses her of being a tart; he grinds his cigarette into her chest. 

Chapter 39 Summary

Eve Mannings comes to the CID, and Ray is the on-duty DI. He asks Kate to see the woman. After the meeting, Kate comes to his office. She reports that Eve Mannings, from Oxford, is trying to find her sister Jennifer from Bristol. She says Eve and Jennifer fell out five years ago, but recently Eve’s brother-in-law stopped by, asking where Jennifer was. Jennifer had apparently sent Eve a postcard, but Eve just found it torn to pieces behind a clock on her mantelpiece. Eve is worried. Ray says the woman isn’t missing; she just doesn’t want to be found.

Ray asks Kate for a drink later. They talk about developments in Tom’s life for a minute, and Ray wonders if Kate ever thinks about that kiss. He takes out his phone, trying to figure out how to tell Mags about going out for a drink with Kate, and decides not to say anything at all.

Chapter 40 Summary

Two weeks later, the bruises have faded enough for Jenna to go out in public. She needs dog food. She can’t help think someone is watching her, though. As she returns to the caravan park, she sees that her old Ford Fiesta has appeared in the lot. It still has a cracked front bumper and a broken windshield. She had left it in Bristol because she couldn’t bear to see it. She thinks she needs to get rid of it, but as she turns the keys in the ignition she remembers the accident. And she hears Ian’s voice. He has recorded a message on a CD in the car stereo system.

 

He asks if she remembers her wedding vows. His voice tells her he only gave her what she asked for. She jabs at the stereo to get the CD out and throws it in the hedge, screaming at him to leave her alone. Then she drives the car into the countryside, leaving it in an abandoned barn and covering with a tarpaulin. She walks home, thinking that in two weeks, she will be in prison and safe.

She takes Beau to the beach for a run. There is a figure on the cliff top, and Beau runs to it. It is Patrick. He mentions that he has left messages, which she knows. He implores her to talk to him and stop running away. It starts to rain. They run to her cottage, and Beau heads up the stairs. Patrick follows, seeing her wooden box before she pushes it under the bed. He tells her he will take care of Beau. She reminds him that it could be years. Patrick says, “Let’s just take each day as it comes” (353). He leaves.

Someone knocks at the door. It is Iestyn. He says he wants her out of the cottage. He cannot handle the pressure he is under from the local people; her guilt is his. And they are starting to shun his wife, Glynis. Jenna has nowhere to go, so she begs to stay until the sentencing. He agrees, but tells her to stay away from the village.

Chapters 36-40 Analysis

Of all the scenes in this book, Jenna’s rape by her husband is the hardest to read. However, the violence is not gratuitous, as it illustrates exactly how Jenna is being terrorized and sharpens the trauma. Author Mackintosh uses this psychological tactic to increase the tension and emotionally impact her readers. It is not a pleasant read, but it is an effective way of persuading audiences to understand and empathize with Jenna’s situation.

 

That is not the only incidence of violence and manipulation reflected in these chapters. Later, he puts his voice on a recording and returns her car to her—the one that killed Jacob. The flashbacks, too, relate this dynamic in their relationship, as Ian details how he lost his attraction to Jenna while engaging in more abuse, including burning her with a cigarette. Clearly, a frightening pattern is being developed here, and Jenna increasingly takes on the qualities of one cowed by years of abuse. Mackintosh, over the course of the book, has done a successful job of developing the complexities of this type of relationship, including the reasons why someone would stay with her abuser. Jenna is completely dependent on Ian financially at this point. She has little contact with her friends and family, and she looks to him for praise, criticism, and almost everything else.

 

The National Coalition Against Domestic Violence, in explaining this dynamic, points out that one of the most dangerous times for victims is when they attempt to leave their abuser, and that factors keeping them in dangerous relationships include “the victim feeling that the relationship is a mix of good times, love and hope along with the manipulation, intimidation and fear” (https://ncadv.org/why-do-victims-stay). This description seems to apply to Jenna’s situation exactly. After these new encounters with Ian, she feels hopeless: “I was stupid to think I could escape the past. However fast I run, however far: I will never outrun it” (322).

To add insult to injury, Jenna has now become a pariah even with those who have become her friends in Penfach, which certainly exacerbate her feelings of isolation and despair. Her recovery seems to have suffered a setback due to these events. Additionally, the broken lock motif returns. After the aggressive rape, Jenna feels understandably vulnerable and demands that that the door be fixed, and the desperation of her demand finally gets through to Iestyn. Yet the safety of the locked door seems fairly brittle in the light of what has already happened.

 

These chapters also bring domestic matters in Bristol to a head, as Ray’s work-wife meets his real wife in an awkward encounter that reveals Mags’ insecurities and leads Kate to beat a hasty exit after dinner. Things seem to be getting better with Tom’s situation, though, as the school wants to meet. However, both Mags and Ray interpret the school’s ambiguous and short letter as admitting there is a problem with bullying their son, but it does not actually read that way.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Related Titles

By Clare Mackintosh